Best Cat Litter in NYC (2025)

Dr. Elsey's Ultra UnScented Clumping Clay Cat Litter 40 lb. Bag

★★★★★4.5

(2,572 verified reviews)

Why We Ranked It #1

Claiming the #1 spot, this cat litter stands out with its 4.5/5 rating from 2,572 reviews. NYC customers consistently praise its reliability and performance for city living.

Key Features

✓To view this video download
✓PREMIUM QUALITY: A combination of premium texture and granule size made with 100% bentonite clay for maximum clumping creates litter particles that are just the right size.
✓LOW DUST: Ideal for cats and owners who suffer from allergies with a 99.9% dust-free and hypoallergenic litter formulation.
✓HARD CLUMPING: Hard clumping medium grain clay helps prevent moisture from reaching the bottom of the tray and forms hard clumps that won't break down, making it easier to scoop.
✓SUPERIOR ODOR CONTROL: Formulated for single or multi-cat households with natural ingredients to keep your home smelling clean and fresh between litter box cleanings.

Great for NYCFast Prime Shipping4.5+ Star RatingTop Seller

Dr. Elsey's Ultra Unscented Clumping Clay Cat Litter 18 lb Bag

★★★★☆4.4

(8,786 verified reviews)

Why We Ranked It #2

Securing the #2 position, this option impressed us with its solid 4.4/5 rating across 8,786 reviews. It's an excellent alternative to our top pick with slightly different strengths.

Key Features

✓To view this video download
✓PREMIUM QUALITY: A combination of premium texture and granule size made with 100% bentonite clay for maximum clumping creates litter particles that are just the right size.
✓LOW DUST: Ideal for cats and owners who suffer from allergies with a 99.9% dust-free and hypoallergenic litter formulation.
✓HARD CLUMPING: Hard clumping medium grain clay helps prevent moisture from reaching the bottom of the tray and forms hard clumps that won't break down, making it easier to scoop.
✓SUPERIOR ODOR CONTROL: Formulated for single or multi-cat households with natural ingredients to keep your home smelling clean and fresh between litter box cleanings.

Great for NYCFast Prime Shipping4.4+ Star RatingTop Seller

Budget Friendly

$14.39

ARM & HAMMER Clump & Seal SLIDE Platinum Multi-Cat Clumping Cat Litter, 14-Day Odor Control, EZ Clean Technology, 18 lbs – No Scrubbing, Powerful Odor Eliminator

★★★★★4.5

(3,714 verified reviews)

Why We Ranked It #3

Rounding out our top 3, this cat litter brings unique advantages that earned its spot. The 4.5/5 rating from 3,714 satisfied customers confirms its quality.

Key Features

✓To view this video download
✓EZ Clean Technology – Patented non-stick formula slides out easily for no-scrub clean-up.
✓14-Day Odor Control Guarantee – Keeps your home fresh with powerful odor eliminators.
✓10% More Odor Eliminators – Enhanced formula with ARM & HAMMER Baking Soda for maximum odor control.
✓Rock-Hard Clumps – Moisture-activated granules form tight clumps for easy scooping.

Great for NYCFast Prime Shipping4.5+ Star RatingTop Seller

Best Overall

$17.48

ARM & HAMMER Clump & Seal Platinum Cat Litter, Multi-Cat, 18 lbs

★★★★★4.6

(28,934 verified reviews)

Why We Ranked It #4

In fourth place, this solid performer offers distinct advantages for specific needs. With 28,934 reviews averaging 4.6/5, it's a reliable choice backed by satisfied customers.

Key Features

✓Seals and destroys odors for 7 days guaranteed
✓Forms rock-hard clumps for easy scooping
✓99% dust-free formula for a cleaner pour
✓Plant-derived particles help keep floors clean

Great for NYCFast Prime Shipping4.6+ Star RatingTop Seller

Best Value

$26.98

Fresh Step Clumping Cat Litter, Multi-Cat, Long Lasting Odor Control Kitty Litter with Activated Charcoal, Low Dust Formula, 14 lb

★★★★★4.5

(2,894 verified reviews)

Why We Ranked It #5

Rounding out our recommendations, this cat litter earned its spot with solid performance and 2,894 positive reviews averaging 4.5/5.

Key Features

✓To view this video download
✓FRESH STEP CLUMPING CAT LITTER: One 14 lb. box of Fresh Step Multi Cat Clumping Litter, Extra Strength Formula With Febreze Freshness, designed for multi cat homes.
✓15 DAYS OF ODOR CONTROL: Ammonia Block technology helps fight multi cat litter box odors and guarantees 15 days of odor control (1).
✓RAPID LIQUID ABSORPTION: Fresh Step Clumping Cat Litter quickly absorbs liquid, ensuring a dry and clean litter box environment for your cat's comfort.
✓FORMS TIGHT CLUMPS: Fresh Step ClumpLock technology locks in liquid and odor on contact and causes immediate kitty litter clumping to make scooping easy and prevent crumbles from being left behind.

Great for NYCFast Prime Shipping4.5+ Star RatingTop Seller