Best Cat Food in NYC (2025)

Purina Cat Chow Naturals With Added Vitamins, Minerals and Nutrients Dry Cat Food, Naturals Original - 13 lb. Bag

★★★★★4.7

(7,713 verified reviews)

Why We Ranked It #1

Claiming the #1 spot, this cat food stands out with its 4.7/5 rating from 7,713 reviews. NYC customers consistently praise its reliability and performance for city living.

Key Features

✓To view this video download
✓Natural nutrition with high-quality ingredients like real chicken as the #1 ingredient for a taste your cat will enjoy
✓Purina indoor cat food made with real salmon and whole grains formulated for all life stages
✓Weight control cat food containing 25 essential vitamins for cats and minerals to support your cat’s overall health
✓Adult cat food delivering 100 percent complete and balanced nutrition including omega-6 fatty acids for skin and coat health

Great for NYCFast Prime Shipping4.7+ Star RatingTop Seller

Best Overall

$46.94

Purina Cat Chow Indoor Healthy Weight and Hairball Dry Cat Food With Chicken - (Pack of 4) 3.15 lb. Bags

★★★★★4.7

(9,729 verified reviews)

Why We Ranked It #2

Our runner-up earns its position with premium quality and outstanding performance. The 4.7/5 rating from 9,729 buyers speaks to its reliability, making it a close second to our top pick.

Key Features

✓To view this video download
✓HIGH-QUALITY CAT FOOD: This Purina Cat Chow Indoor Healthy Weight and Hairball with chicken cat food features a high-quality recipe with a great taste.
✓FARM-RAISED CHICKEN: Our Purina dry cat food is made with real, farm-raised chicken that supports healthy weight and hairball control.
✓OMEGA-6 FATTY ACIDS: The cat kibble dry food is formulated with omega-6 fatty acids to help keep your cat looking and feeling her best.
✓25 ESSENTIAL VITAMINS AND MINERALS: Our wholesome Purina cat food contains 25 vitamins and minerals to support your cat's overall health and wellbeing.

Great for NYCFast Prime Shipping4.7+ Star RatingTop Seller

Premium Pick

$51.99

Purina Cat Chow Hairball, Healthy Weight, Indoor, Natural Dry Cat Food, Naturals Indoor - 13 lb. Bag

★★★★★4.7

(9,771 verified reviews)

Why We Ranked It #3

Taking third place, this premium option is worth the investment for those wanting top-tier performance. Its 4.7/5 rating from 9,771 buyers reflects exceptional build quality.

Key Features

✓To view this video download
✓Natural Purina dry cat food nutrition with high-quality ingredients like real turkey and real chicken as the #1 ingredient for a taste your cat will enjoy
✓Hairball control cat food features a natural fiber blend to help control hairballs
✓25 essential vitamins for cats and minerals to support your cat’s overall health
✓Weight control cat food delivering 100 percent complete and balanced nutrition specially formulated to promote your cat’s healthy weight

Great for NYCFast Prime Shipping4.7+ Star RatingTop Seller

Budget Friendly

$28.98

Hill's Science Diet Indoor, Adult 1-6, Easy Litter Box Cleanup, Dry Cat Food, Chicken Recipe, 7 lb Bag

★★★★★4.7

(3,393 verified reviews)

Why We Ranked It #4

In fourth place, this solid performer offers distinct advantages for specific needs. With 3,393 reviews averaging 4.7/5, it's a reliable choice backed by satisfied customers.

Key Features

✓To view this video download
✓Made with natural fibers to promote healthy digestion and easy litter box clean-up
✓Easy to digest ingredients for a flavorful, nutritious meal
✓High quality protein for lean muscles
✓Made in the USA with global ingredients you can trust

Great for NYCFast Prime Shipping4.7+ Star RatingTop Seller

Blue Buffalo Tastefuls Natural Dry Food for Adult Indoor Cats, Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe, 7-lb. Bag

★★★★★4.7

(5,622 verified reviews)

Why We Ranked It #5

Rounding out our recommendations, this cat food earned its spot with solid performance and 5,622 positive reviews averaging 4.7/5.

Key Features

✓To view this video download
✓REAL CHICKEN FIRST: This Blue Buffalo cat food is made in the USA with real, high-quality chicken as the #1 ingredient
✓IDEAL FOR ADULT CATS: Dry indoor cat food formulated with natural sources of fiber and nutrients for digestive care and coat health
✓IMMUNE SYSTEM SUPPORT: Healthy adult dry cat food contains exclusive, antioxidant-rich LifeSource Bits
✓HEALTHY, WHOLESOME INGREDIENTS: This indoor cat food is made with no chicken (or poultry) by-product meals and no corn, wheat, or soy

Great for NYCFast Prime Shipping4.7+ Star RatingTop Seller