Best Fertilizer in NYC (2025)

Scotts Turf Builder Lawn Food, Fertilizes and Strengthens Grass to Protect Against Future Problems, 15,000 sq. ft.

★★★★★4.6

(4,512 verified reviews)

Why We Ranked It #1

Claiming the #1 spot, this fertilizer stands out with its 4.6/5 rating from 4,512 reviews. NYC customers consistently praise its reliability and performance for city living.

Key Features

✓FEEDS AND STRENGTHENS - Strengthens grass against heat and drought while building thick, green turf
✓LARGE COVERAGE - Treats up to 15,000 square feet of lawn area
✓IMPROVES LAWN'S ABILITY - Helps lawn absorb water and nutrients versus unfed lawn
✓APPLY WITH SPREADER - Best applied with Scotts lawn spreader for even distribution

Great for NYCFast Prime Shipping4.6+ Star RatingTop Seller

Premium Pick

$49.99

Miracle-Gro Pour & Feed Plant Food, Fertilizer Instantly Feeds Live Plants, For Outdoor & Indoor Plants in Containers, 32 oz.

★★★★★4.8

(4,793 verified reviews)

Why We Ranked It #2

Securing the #2 position, this option impressed us with its solid 4.8/5 rating across 4,793 reviews. It's an excellent alternative to our top pick with slightly different strengths.

Key Features

✓To view this video download
✓Ready-to-use plant food, no mixing required
✓No mixing with water - simply apply directly to the soil
✓Instantly feeds all potted plants
✓For indoor and outdoor container plants

Great for NYCFast Prime Shipping4.8+ Star RatingTop Seller

Best Value

$49.99

Espoma Potash 0-0-60 Potassium Fertilizer. Use for All Plants requiring Potash Supplement Including Trees, Shrubs, Vegetables and Flowers. Granular for Easy Application. 6 lb. Bag

★★★★★4.7

(1,627 verified reviews)

Why We Ranked It #3

Rounding out our top 3, this fertilizer brings unique advantages that earned its spot. The 4.7/5 rating from 1,627 satisfied customers confirms its quality.

Key Features

✓To view this video download
✓CONTAINS: Potash is an enriched source of potassium; 0-0-60 fertilizer analysis with no sludges or fillers
✓FOR USE ON: Use for Trees, Shrubs, Flowers & Vegetables; Promotes plant vigor and disease-resistance
✓AVAILABLE: Comes in 6 lb. resealable bag
✓MADE IN THE USA: Product of the Espoma Company

Great for NYCFast Prime Shipping4.7+ Star RatingTop Seller

Miracle-Gro Indoor Plant Food, Plant Fertilizer, 8 oz. (6-Pack)

★★★★★4.5

(5,306 verified reviews)

Why We Ranked It #4

In fourth place, this solid performer offers distinct advantages for specific needs. With 5,306 reviews averaging 4.5/5, it's a reliable choice backed by satisfied customers.

Key Features

✓To view this video download
✓Instantly feeds all indoor houseplants
✓For all indoor plants, including edibles
✓Able to apply directly to the soil or can mix with water

Great for NYCFast Prime Shipping4.5+ Star RatingTop Seller

Best Overall

$49.99

Scotts Green Max Lawn Fertilizer, Lawn Fertilizer with Iron Supplement, Makes Grass Greener, Fast, 5,000 sq. ft., 16 lbs.

★★★★★4.7

(3,640 verified reviews)

Why We Ranked It #5

Rounding out our recommendations, this fertilizer earned its spot with solid performance and 3,640 positive reviews averaging 4.7/5.

Key Features

✓MAKES GRASS GREEN FAST - Iron-fortified formula delivers deep greening in just 3 days
✓COVERS 5,000 SQ FT - Ideal for medium-sized lawns and targeted treatment areas
✓IRON SUPPLEMENT - Contains iron to correct nutrient deficiencies and enhance color
✓FEEDS AND GREENS - Combines fertilizer nutrients with iron for comprehensive lawn care

Great for NYCFast Prime Shipping4.7+ Star RatingTop Seller